Establishing a Sustainable Dairy Enterprise by Prof. Dr. Riaz Virk

Author:
Prof. Dr. Riaz Virk
Director Institute of Animal & Dairy Sciences
University of Agriculture, Faisalabad

Author: Prof. Dr. Riaz Virk Director Institute of Animal & Dairy Sciences University of Agriculture, Faisalabad




Dairying is one of the most important means of providing livelihood and nutritional security to the rural masses. The importance of dairy enterprise in the national economy can be gauged from the fact that the value of output from milk is nearly one-fourth of the value from the agricultural sector. The livestock activities, among which dairy farming predominates, employ about 8.5 million workers in the country. Milk and milk products account for 9.2 and 12.4 percent of protein intake in rural and urban areas, respectively. This article strives to evaluate the techno-economic viability of small, medium, and large-sized commercial model dairy farms. 

Before entering in dairy business one should check related information and answer these questions; 

  • Which one from the above-given dairy sub-sectors is the best for him and in which he has got skills/knowledge or resources? 
  • If he has got knowledge or skills then what is the level of these skills? 
  • Can he execute business alone or will he need the help of professionals? 
  • How much capital does he have? 
  • Is it enough to start and sustain the business during hardship? 
  • What is his vision? 
  • Does he want to run a small business or target the mega-industry? 
  • How can he achieve these targets? 
  • What resources does he use to reach these targets? 
  • Has he got a loyal team? 
  • Is his team professionally sound to achieve these targets and able to solve different problems and meet challenges that will come along? 
  • Animal production is not only a single-dimensional phenomenon of increasing animal production but now it is a multidimensional approach with targets to get safe animal products and efficient utilization of natural resources with minimum environmental pollution. 


These prerequisites are discussed in detail below:

Prerequisites: 

The major requirements for the setting up of a dairy farm are the availability of quality animals, land for the construction of sheds and for the production of fodder, and capital for the purchase of dairy animals, construction of dairy sheds and allied structures along with the purchase of equipment and machinery. It would be ideal if the entrepreneur owns enough land for construction of the cattle sheds and to grow fodder. Alternatively, the land for the production of fodder can be taken on lease or the fodder can be purchased from the market. The capital required could be raised through loans from nationalized banks which can be repaid in easy installments.


Choice of dairy animal: 

The choice of dairy animal will depend on the demand of milk and market price of the milk. It would be worthwhile to conduct a market survey of the potential area where the farm is to be set up regarding the consumer preferences for cow or buffalo milk and the comparative prices offered. However it would be advisable to initially start with both cows and buffaloes in suitable combination and subsequently depending on the demand and price of milk increase the number of cows or the buffaloes as the case may be.  It is advised to start with high yielding cows/buffaloes as feed cost per kg of milk comes down as the yield of animal increases. It is better to purchase the animals in two batches. The second batch should be purchased when the animals of first batch are in late stage of lactation so that the production level is maintained more or less uniform throughout the year.


Housing: The land required for the construction of dairy sheds and ancillary structures including the milking parlor, maternity pens, straw store, feed store, implements room, milk room, chaff cutter shed, manure pit, roads and alleys between and office, etc. works out to be about 500 sq. ft. per animal for a dairy unit of 20 animals. The land required is reduced to about 350 sq. ft. per animal if the herd strength is increased to 50 animals or higher as the area required for the milk room, roads and alleys, chaff cutter shed, office, implements room does not increase proportionately. Per animal area will be further reduced if the farm size is further increased. The dairy building should be made of locally available cheap construction materials and very costly building structures and expensive sheds should be avoided.


Sustainable Feed/Fodder supply: The other important requirement for setting up of a successful commercial dairy farm is the land for fodder cultivation. The land should be well fertile with assured irrigation facilities so that all the seasonal fodder crops could be successfully raised and abundant good quality green fodder is available for feeding throughout the year. The land is required for the construction of dairy sheds and other farm structures as well as for the production of fodder. The land required for fodder production depends on the carrying capacity of the land. On an average 4 to 5 dairy animals along with their followers can be maintained on an acre of well fertile agricultural land with assured irrigation facilities. However, the farm productivity would be higher and the cost of milk production is lower if farm grown good quality green fodder is available in plenty. After following the total mixed rations (TMR) based feeding regime, the requirement of land for fodder cultivation can be suitably reduced. The place where the dairy farm is to be set up should have a source of good quality water for drinking by animals and for the cleaning, washing etc. the dairy farm equipment & premises. The cost of milk production is lower if cows are fed on good quality abundant green fodders and homemade quality concentrate mixture.


Laborers: 

Dairy farming is a labor-intensive enterprise as compared to crop production and other allied enterprises. It has been estimated that on average one person can look after all activities of 10 milking animals along with their followers excluding the work of harvesting fodder. Some routine activities such as milking (machine as well as hand milking), heat detection, care of down-calvers and neonates, etc. require experienced and dedicated workers. Therefore in case one decides to set up a new farm about half of the workers should have earlier experience of working at a dairy farm. Two or three workers have to be trained for the specialized jobs at the dairy farm such as AI, first aid, identification, de-worming etc. Besides, at large farms technically qualified persons in the field of dairying will have to be hired such as the farm manager, veterinarian, stockman, and the ministerial staff.


Mechanization: On farms maintaining more than 20 milch animals, machine milking may be economical and more convenient as compared to hand milking. Installation of fans and mist cooling devices in animal sheds for protection against heat stress is also a must if one wishes to keep high yielding crossbred cows. Dairy farms with 50 or more milch animals may also require a milk cooler, electricity generator set and a utility vehicle for the procurement of farm supplies and marketing of produce besides a tractor with implements for the cultivation of fodders and their harvesting, transportation chaffing, processing etc. However, at a large dairy farm integrated with a milk processing plant or situated in the milk shed area of a milk processing plant with a high level of mechanization and automation keeping of high milk producing crossbred cows is likely to be more economical than the buffaloes.


Adoption of Improved Technologies: To believe that the modernization would always be at the cost of the animal welfare may not be always true. To the contrary, many developments in housing, feeding, milking and other areas of animal production have helped to ensure improved wellbeing of the animals. Modern housing designs, milking parlor, mistress cooling devises, chilled drinking water during summers, individual bedded pens for young calves, exercise before calving, night feeding to ensure higher rate of day time calving, mechanical lifting of excreta etc. could all contribute to better animal welfare.  Some standard practices with temporary painful procedures like, dehorning, dystocia management, castration, identification methods, foot care, removal of extra teats in young age etc. can be justified in terms of long term welfare of the animals.


Marketing: The market price of the milk is the major determinant of the profitability of dairy farming. The removal of middlemen in milk marketing and selling the milk directly to consumers is therefore a must for sustainable and viable dairy farming. In fact most of commercial milk producers in the country comprise of this category who market milk readily in cities by themselves. The cornerstone of successful dairying is the elimination of middlemen in the marketing of milk and the producers themselves have to devise their marketing mechanism so that the producers directly sells the milk and value added milk products to the consumers. The price of cow milk is lower than the buffalo milk due to lower milk fat content. There may be lower consumer preference for fresh cow milk. The higher grades of crosses though producing higher milk may not be adapted to all climatic conditions prevailing in the country. The buffalo males after weaning and other unwanted animals also fetch good price as meat animals. The buffalo males are also good work animals. However higher calf mortality, slower rate of growth, late maturity and higher calving interval (15-18 months) are some of the detriments in buffalo farming. The net income will have a upward swing from the fourth year onwards as farm born high producing fresh cows are added and low producing old cows are sold out from the herd.


Small to Medium Scale Dairying: An average farm family desirous of venturing into a commercial scale dairy farming as a specialized occupation may initially start with about 20-30 dairy animals extendable to 50 dairy animals, preferably a combination of crossbred cows and buffaloes. Such a farm unit shall provide full time employment to 2-3 workmen and shall generate sufficient income to sustain a middle class family. Further construction of modern animal housing facilities, mechanical fodder chaffing, machine milking, milk chilling and other infrastructure shall be better utilized and economically viable if the farm size comprises a minimum of 30 high-yielding dairy cows.  The size of the farm can be raised gradually to 50 animals or more in the proportion of 25 cows and 25 buffaloes as the farmer stabilizes in dairying. The established business firms having the necessary capital for investing in dairy production and who are in a position to hire technical personnel for the management of the farm may set up large dairy farms starting with 100 to 500 high-grade crossbred cows and a suitable number of superior buffaloes and gradually raise the farm size further as per requirement. It will be prudent to start from a small size as a large number of animals with desired production levels may not be available or difficult to procure at the same time. Further, the farm-bred cows, under ideal management conditions, will be better producers than the purchased cows.  


Crossbred Cow v/s Buffalo Dairy Farms: The potential entrepreneur may start the dairy farm either with crossbred cows or with improved breeds of buffaloes or a rightful combination of both high-yielding crossbred cows and buffaloes.


Crossbred Cow Farms: The important economic characteristics to be considered while selecting the dairy animal are: Crossbred cows are the economical producers of milk under good feeding and management conditions. They are high producers of milk with production levels of 4000 to 5000 kg of milk in standard lactation quite attainable. The level of exotic inheritance of half-bred can further be upgraded to 62.5 and even up to 75 percent in subsequent generations as the husbandry practices get stabilized and the dairy entrepreneur gets experience in the management of high-grade cows.  These high-grade cows can produce under local conditions of feeding and management an average of about 5000 to 6000 kg of milk in a lactation period. The average milk fat content of crossbred cows is low (3.5 to 4.0 %) as compared to buffaloes and indigenous cows. They grow at a faster rate mature early and come into production at about 28 to 30 months of age. They breed comparatively regularly if proper care is given and produce one calf every 13-14 months. In hilly regions and coastal areas Jersey crosses may be more suitable. They are more amenable to modern husbandry practices such as calf weaning and machine milking. In fact, many such farms with high levels of mechanization including mechanical feeding, cleaning, machine milking, and other modernized management aids coming up in the country are looking to maintain the high-grade crossbred cows. These are available in sufficient numbers in some established markets at reasonable prices. The male crossbred cattle calves can also be used for meat purposes.


Buffalo Dairy Farms: Good breeds of buffaloes like Nili-Ravi and Kundi are economical producers of milk and thus suitable for commercial dairy farming. Elite buffaloes belonging can yield 3000-3500 kg or even more milk in lactation. The buffalo milk is rich in fat content which usually ranges from 6.0 to 9.0 percent and is thus priced around 30-40 % higher than the cow milk. Moreover, buffaloes could be maintained on fibrous feed residues and hence offer higher scope for reducing feed costs. Buffaloes are well adapted under the diversified agro-climatic conditions of the country and are less likely to suffer from mastitis, milk fever and parasitic infestations as compared to crossbred cows.


Commercial dairy farms: It is the need of hour is to promote dairy farming on commercial lines in the country. This would not only provide a quantum jump in the milk production but would also benefits to address the quality issues. Commercial dairy farms to be set up near the urban areas to take advantage of the higher milk prices round the year without involving middlemen or the commercial farms are to be integrated with milk processing units. There would be the lesser transportation charges and lesser will be the loss due to spoilage of highly perishable milk and milk products during storage and transportation. Ideally the big dairy farms should be located nearer to towns but not in towns due to the compliance of environmental protocols and higher costs of inputs especially fodder make them difficult to sustain. Dairy farming units are opened at safe distance from the municipal limits, can earn good returns as they can sell milk at high prices to the consumers directly.


Smart dairy farming: It is generally defined as information and technology-based farm management system to identify, analyse and manage variability within farm management for optimum farm performance, profitability and sustainability. It is technology based measures and analyses for physiological values, behavioural display and production indicators in individual animals. Automated milking systems save labour in addition to milk recording individual animal and total yield of animals at a dairy farm. Milk recording system for daily milk yield and changes in intake is made easy. Activity monitors detect abnormal activity, warning signs of illness or infection. Pedometer’s use helps to tracks cow activity and helps in breeding. Record keeping and digital monitoring with the use of computer, tablet, and phone apps collect data for farmer’s future decisions. Automated calf feeders are adjustable for the calves' age & weight to grow faster and stay healthy. The calf carries a transponder to follow a daily intake for a computer-controlled milk-feeding system fairly well. Systems can also be combined with automatic weighing and health observation for calf welfare and ease in farm operations, animal welfare, production efficiency, and profitability. Innovative technological applications could be used to monitor the welfare of animals, physiological status, and early identification of diseases. Electronic records for milking, heat detection, weighing, and barn environment are routine demands of dairy farm operations. Some sensors are available for auto-disease detection and physiological data recording.

 

      Conclusions: The following points should be kept in mind while starting a dairy enterprise;
1-     Before starting a business get complete overall information or a SWOT test is a must.
2-      Always get services of professional people to prepare a business plan.
3-      Short introductory courses in this respect could be helpful.
4-      Ask a professional to do economic analysis of your farm after every financial year.
5-      Always try to be pioneer in adopting innovative technology to get early benefits. 

Comments